The Purpose of this Blog

Your task on this blog is to write a brief summary of what we learned in class today. Include enough detail so that someone who was ill or missed the class can catch up with what they missed. Over the course of the term, these 'class scribe' posts will grow to be a guide for the course, written by students for students.

With each post ask yourself the following questions:
1) Is this good enough for our guide?
2) Will your post enable someone who wasnt here to catch up?
3) Would a graphic/video/link help to illustrate what we have learned?

Saturday, 2 October 2010

The Uncanny by Shaun Akturk

We started off by understanding Freud's theory of; "Heimlich" (Something homelike - a feeling of something that is "agreeable" and "acceptable") and the "Un-heimlich" (The un-homelike - something that the reader feels "out of place" or "falsely placed"). We as literature students must understand that these terms do not oppose each other. "The Un-heimlich sets up a different kind of existence". It is clear through the word “different" the uncanny is a scenario of ambivalence, and not the expected ideas of opposition.

The Uncanny is the Heimlich invading the Un-Heimlich or vice versa.

We later attempted to understand and discuss what David Punters adaptation of "The Uncanny" in relation to Gothic meant. Specifically looking at chapter 3 of "Wuthering Heights" Lockwood’s dream contains strong links the uncanny, as far as David Punter is concerned. Punter, states that dreams are constructed by the Heimlich (Evidently, even the most bizarre ideas of the dreamer, put forward in the dream are considered Heimlich, as it is conjured up through a Heimlich character.)

The uncanny, can be found both in the structure and characters chronology of W.Heights. The layered structure which narrates from a mix of past and present, something Punter describes as the "fabric of time". In which the Un-heimlich being the past invading the Heimlich present. Readers will see this in the filtered narration, in its structure and physically upon characters. The narration sequence ranging from the past Nelly reveals and the present of Lockwood. Catherine Linton's ghost a character of the past attacks the Heimlich present, that Lockwood lives in literally - Lockwood tells us his "fingers closed on the fingers of a little ice-cold hand!...The intense horror. The fact that the horror facet of Gothic literature is exposed here evokes a similar sense of fear from the reader. Furthermore this is a prime example of "the uncanny". Punters notion of the uncanny suggest that what is possible, likely and authorised in literature is in fact "unstable" in Gothic - ultimately anything is possible. Writers use the uncanny, as gaps in a kaput shield, which readers use to hide away from the monsters such as Dracula, Frankenstein monster and Catherine Linton.

We were asked to write up about the uncanny...Here is mine its a bit weak but, I just wanted to be able to revise from it easily later on in the year...

"Lockwood thinking pattern of reality is disturbed, because of his touching of the "ice-cold hand" his logical understanding is in invaded by the Un-heimlich - a physical sense of horror from the Heimlich character Lockwood. Freud concept of a combination between the Heimlich and Un-heimlich (the uncanny) is exposed to a gothic text because of Punters own ideas. Where he suggests the narrative structuring of Wuthering Heights is evidently contains strong references to the notion of the Un-heimlich invading the Heimlich.

The "fabric of time" whereby the past invades into the universal Heimlich of present time - is exactly what happens in W.H. The generic chronological order of narration is not present in W.H and this creates an enigmatic and ambivalent text, where readers are disturbed by the misunderstood layers of an unorganised and unstable text. The filters that create the story are provided by Nelly a symbol of the past, and Lockwood a more present and modern character. The invasion of "Catherine Linton’s... Ice-cold finger" affects the pragmatic world of Lockwood. Readers are positioned to view the order of events just as Lockwood does. If we were to consider ourselves Lockwood it would be acceptable to say that our own misshapen understanding chronological events and the supernatural, surface and evoke a genuine sense of fear (containing both horror and terror elements).

Characters are also trapped into this sense of the uncanny. Heathcliff character feels the invasion from the "different" Lockwood. The reader a character in it self, is categorized into the "uncanny of the monumental". The excessiveness of Heathcliff over powers our own worldly concerns and displaces our understanding of a conventional style of life, because of the extremeness and distorted equilibrium in the world of the Wuthering Heights and the its Heimlich characters."

It would be good if everyone could write their own essay on this blog, and place a comment as it will help everyone else in developing their own ideas.

14 comments:

  1. HOMEWORK...
    FINISH CHAPTER SUMMARISE UP TO 5.
    COMMENT ON BLOG.
    READ ARTICLE ON BOUNDARIES.

    CH4:
    HOW IS HEATHCLIFF DESCRIBED IN THIS CHAPTER? EXAMINE THE LANGUAGE IN DETAIL.

    HOW DO WE AS READERS RESPOND TO HEATHCLIFF AT THIS POINT IN THE NOVEL GIVEN WHAT WE ALREADY KNOW ABOUT HIM?

    ReplyDelete
  2. why chapter 5....aww mr sadss why maynnn?....kmt...ok den....good blog shaun Thankyou...had difficulty understanding that german stuff but now its clear...tanx !

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mr sadss? maynn? ok den? Oh dear.

    Good detail Shaun - some parts of this are really good. Well done.Be sure to include a discussion of the uncanny in any consideration of the terror of Gothic novels - really good A03 stuff. Also dont forget to use and analyse detail from the text to back up your ideas about terror/the uncanny .(A02)

    ReplyDelete
  4. yh i agree with Mr Sadss good points about Lockwoods dream being invaded by unheimlich. What do u mean about "writers use the uncanny as gaps in a kaput shield"?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Really like the amount of detail. Made how the effects of the uncanny fit into Wuthering Heights much clearer to me. Like Carlo said what do you mean about the 'kaput shield?'

    ReplyDelete
  6. no idea what a "kaput shield" is lol

    but this cleared up alot of confusion about the uncanny within wuthering heights, pretty good job man, thanks

    (i almost cried when i saw georgina's comment lol)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Okay "Kaput" means not working, non-functional in this case.

    Re-reading it I could have worded it much better.

    Basically I felt that the uncanny is a tool which Bronte used to show the "vulnerability" of the reader.
    What I meant by "Kaput Shield" was that a reader of Gothic will sub consciously defend it self from the conventional monsters in the Gothic, hence the shield. The gaps a more important part of the phrase, are symbolic for the the lack of defence from a reader of Gothic, due to the idea of the uncanny and how it makes the reader feel "uncomfortable" and "out of place"

    To sum it up - Kaput shield is almost like a secret weapon that writers use to catch the reader off guard...This is because of how it is such an "un-authorised" combination of ideas (the heimlich and unheimlich)

    Does that make any sense? if it dont sorry...
    and lol Georgina :D someones gonna have a busy night :D

    ReplyDelete
  8. Also the unexpected nature of the uncanny and how it establishes itself to an unprepared reader.
    We might even say that the uncanny is unheimlich to a reader.

    Also thanks for the question it kinda improve mu own ideas aswell. (if that is even possible)

    ReplyDelete
  9. nice blog, really helps to cement the understanding of the uncanny, both on its own and in relation to the gothic.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. thanks for the good post Shaun it cleared lots of things up and made it easy to remember. georgina suck it up babe lol.

    ReplyDelete
  12. So would you guys vote for me, for best blogger? obviously you cant vote for yourself....

    ReplyDelete
  13. Solid blogging Shaun and good responses to questions. (Be sure not to use the term 'kaput shield' in your exam though i understand what you mean). As a class you're all going really well with this. Im impressed how you're using it. Better than my year 12s. (Apart from Georgina's disrespectful kmts and other foul language that is...)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Shaun, you will always get my vote for best blogger. As sad as it may be.
    This post is really informative and clear which is crucial in understanding the complext definition of the 'uncanny' as Zia said, both on its own and in relation to the Gothic.
    I also love the idea of the 'Kaput Shield', too bad we cant use it in our exam :/

    ReplyDelete